Skip to main content

Out of Office: Puppy Love

Out of Office is our new series that explores what faculty are up to when they're off campus.

Louise Epstein with her dogsToby is a seven-year-old West Highland White Terrier (also known as a “westie”) living a charmed life in the hills of northwest Austin. He’s got two westie playmates, a Tempur-Pedic dog bed, a wild backyard covered in doggy-sized walking trails and owners whom the word “doting” does not even come close to describing.

And yet just one year ago, Toby was days from death, suffering from a severe mouth infection that had rotted 20 of his teeth. His new owner, Louise Epstein, wasn’t sure if he would survive the surgery to pull the infected teeth, but she hoped the medicine might provide a few moments of pain-free existence if he succumbed.

Epstein, MBA ’85 and the 2010-11 McCombs entrepreneur-in-residence, adopted Toby from a Williamson County rescue group that had taken him in from a nearby shelter. The shelter had received Toby along with several dozen other dogs from a puppy mill in Brownwood, Texas, whose owner dumps dogs at the shelter annually after they become too sick to breed. At the puppy mill, Toby had spent his life in a wire cage too small for him to stand up in, stacked in a tower exposed to other dogs’ waste and disease, and never going outside or receiving veterinary care.

Epstein is now working with the Texas Humane Legislation Network to pass the Large Scale Commercial Breeder Bill in the 2011 Texas legislative session. The bill, which aims to regulate commercial breeding (defined as an operation with 11 or more breeding females that sells offspring), was defeated in the 2009 session. But Epstein has personally met with every lawmaker who voted against it, sharing Toby’s story and the details of the bill. She has convinced all but one to vote yes this time around.

“I’m a doer, and when I saw this injustice, I was compelled to do something about it,” Epstein says. “I didn’t have a choice. My heart was broken and I would not have been able to sleep if I didn’t do everything I could possibly do to increase awareness and end the suffering. At one mill, there were 1,000 dogs living in squalor. Living painful, miserable existences. It’s the worst of humanity that creates these conditions.”

The bill was originally defeated by a lobbying group that deemed it anti-business, so Epstein pitched the bill as a money-maker to legislators.

“This is a revenue-positive bill, because currently the puppy mills are operating in the shadows, not paying sales tax,” explains Epstein. “The bill requires them to register with the state, pay a licensing fee, and to pay sales tax, like everyone else.”

The bill also provides for the size of the kennel where a dog can stand up normally and turn around and have a solid floor, instead of wire caging. It stipulates that dogs are seen by a vet, that they get nutritious food and that they’re let out of their cages once a day.

Some friends and colleagues have been surprised by Epstein’s crusade, but she says it’s just a part of who she is and not unrelated to her roots in business.

“These are absolutely the same skills I have used as an entrepreneur,” Epstein says. “The being a doer, seeing clearly what the problems are, what the obstacles are, what the solution is and then going out and doing it—it’s the same model.”

When Epstein first brought Toby home, one eye was swollen shut and his white fur was severely discolored with rust and urine stains. He was afraid of everything, even treats, and he didn’t have the muscle development to do simple tasks like climb stairs or lay down comfortably. But now, most signs of his prior life are gone, save the brownish color of his fur, a literal mark of how far he’s come.

“There are people who accept things the way they are, and there are people who it never occurred to them to accept things the way they are,” Epstein says. “I saw this situation, and it was like, ‘No, this is wrong, I need to change this.’ Everything is possible. Especially in America, when you’re on the side of justice.”

And puppies.

How to Avoid Buying from a Puppy Mill

Whether you’re looking for a mutt or pure-breed, lap-dog or jock, here are Epstein’s tips to make sure you’re getting your new playmate from a reputable source.

  • Don’t buy over the internet or classified ads unless you visit the site and see the breeding stock. A quality breeder will be proud to show off his facilities.
  • Reputable breeders guarantee the health of a dog and will buy back a dog that a vet determines is sick.
  • Consider adopting from a shelter or rescue group. The fees are usually much lower, and you can even browse online by breed, age and other characteristics. “There are almost 200,000 dogs in rescue on,” says Epstein of the website where she found Toby. “No matter what kind of dog you want—even pure breeds—you can find it in rescue.”

Visit UT's KNOW to watch a video of Epstein discussing both her roles as entrepreneur-in-residence and an animal welfare activist.

Louise Epstein with her dogs


#1 My hat is off to her

My hat is off to her perseverance and never say die attitude. Many puppies are bred in horrible environments. I love it when I read articles that bring the issue to light, but then also provide solutions. Unfortunately it is hard to completely eradicate this issue, but it is a start in the correct direction. I agree with Louise that it is smart to do your diligence before purchasing your new friend. Thank you for taking on the crusade, rescuing a dog, and illuminating others to the situation. - Jack Lucas nobrainerdogtrainer

#2 Oh Jennifer--you have had a

Oh Jennifer--you have had a sip of the kool-aid. How anyone could oppose minimum standards of care, is incomprehensible. Even the Texas Legislature disagrees with you. And Governor Perry signed the Bill. Why Puppy Mills should be allowed to let their animals live in waste, as Toby did, without ever having medical care, is something that no decent human being should tolerate. There is no excuse for abusing animals. Period. Good breeders already treat their animals with excellent care. Why good breeders have been unwilling to distinguish themselves from those those who abuse the animals in their trust, is very strange indeed. Most professions want to separate the good from the bad. It is GOOD for the profession to do so. The sad truth is this: breeding dogs and cats without caring from them is a way to turn a quick buck. You should be ashamed of yourself for defending those who care nothing about the animals in their care.

#3 Toby is doing great. He is

Toby is doing great. He is our miracle. He loves his terrier family and his two cats. The way he looks at them, it is as if he is saying "those are the strangest dogs I have ever met". Toby changed Texas Law. I am forever grateful.

#4 these 3 little rascals are

these 3 little rascals are just adorables.

#5 Hey, great article, i never

Hey, great article, i never realized how bad the problem was :( did Toby make it through in the end do you know?! Laura - Webmaster @ puppy training

#6 Cheers to another Westie

Cheers to another Westie lady! I coordinate a Westie rescue in Texas and have a mill dog myself, as well as the puppies she had when the baby came to me pregnant. I had many of the same experiences she had with her little rescue boy. Ms. Epstein is completely correct about everything she's doing, except for her support and advocacy for this awful bill. I am certain her intentions are good, but this particular bill only makes operations more expensive and burdensome for legitimate, responsible breeders. For example, if 5 people are partners in the same kennel and are keeping 3 breeding females each in their own homes as well cared for pets, this bill still treats them as a mill. People who run mills will never comply with any of these laws and it will drive them further underground; making them better at evasion and ultimately being worse for the animals. Further, the enforcement problems with this bill are immense. You want to stop mills in Texas? Dry up the demand. We as individuals must educate people to never buy a dog from a pet store or from people who sell them on the side of the road. Always insist to see the parents and the kennel facilities. Ask about health certifications and guarantees. All this advocacy would be so much better spent on a campaign to educate people about responsible pet acquisition and ownership instead of being used as a tool by organizations who want to ban all of us from ever owning pets. If Ms. Epstein is truly interested in learning all of the facts about breeding and how to focus her efforts in a truly positive and game changing way, I would love to meet her and introduce her to an entire society of responsible breeders and owners. She's welcome to contact me anytime. Jennifer Garrison President & Rescue Coordinator West Highland White Terrier Club of Southeast Texas

#7 This is such a touching

This is such a touching story. Thank you. Thank you for being such a wonderful human being!

#8 Thank you and god bless you.

Thank you and god bless you. You truly are very inspiring

#9 Thank you Ms. Epstein for

Thank you Ms. Epstein for your hard work and dedication! You are truly an inspiration to others. Bless you!

#10 Here is the site through

Here is the site through to support the Texas Puppy Mill ban:

Post a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.